Catalina United Methodist Church Home
Sunday Morning Live!
A Contemporary Service
 
Soul Talk
by Jonathan Arnpriester
 
December 10, 2000
 
The Christ We Never Knew December 10, 2000
Psalm 25:1-10

Never in the history of the United State of America,

has the political lexicon
been expanded so rapidly
in the public consciousness
as in the last 35 days.

St. Chad was the seventh-century

abbot of Lastingham,
and bishop successively
of York and Lichfield, England
who died in Ad. 672.
He was probably Northumbrian by birth
and educated at Lindisfarne under St. Aidan.

Later, he went to Ireland

where he studied
in the monastery of Melfont.
He returned
to help his brother St. Cedd
establish the monastery of
Lastingham in Yorkshire.
On his brother's death in 664,
he succeeded him as abbot.

But that's not the end of the story.

Shortly afterward,

St. Wilfrid,
who had been appointed
to succeed the vacant bishop of York,
went to Gaul
to be consecrated for the post,
but he stayed away so long that
the king grew impatient
and pushed through the election of Chad
as bishop of York instead.

Chad was duly consecrated

by two British bishops,
and began his work as bishop,
visiting the faithful on foot,
and serving the diocese
in a cordial apostolic spirit.

However,

he had not been consecrated
to his new duties
by the Archbishop of Canterbury
because this bishopric
was also vacant at the time.

This would prove to be a problem.

When Theodore,
the newly consecrated archbishop,
arrived at Canterbury,
he announced that
St. Chad must give up the diocese
to St. Wilfrid,
who had now returned.

When he further suggested that

St. Chad's episcopal consecration
had not been properly performed,
St. Chad replied,
"If you decide that
I have not rightly received the episcopal character,
I willingly lay down the office;
for I have never thought myself worthy of it,
but under obedience,
I, though unworthy,
consented to undertake it."

In other words,

Chad had the courage to concede.

I'm fairly frustrated with

what I've seen happen since Nov 7.
Gore won the popular vote.
Bush seems to have
the Electoral college sewn up.
Both have reason to push to win.
I think my admiration for either
would go up
if one of them conceded.

St. Chad illustrated

an immense amount of humility.
And in my experience
good leadership comes
when humility is the key value.
Anything else is management at best,
control and ego at worst.

So where's the humility?

If I were to ask you to think about Jesus,

what is the first image that comes to mind?
Teacher by the sea?
Healer in the crowd?
Leader in the middle?
Mystic on the mountain?
I want to invite you to another image,
one we don't ponder very often...
Jesus of conundrums,
of conflict...
an image we get
when Jesus is a boy of 12
who goes to the temple
and astounds and confounds the religious teachers...
as he clears the temple with a stick...

An image that starts before his birth.

Read text: Psalm 25:1-10

By any kind of reckoning,

it shouldn't have been there.
But it was.

In one of the hottest summers on record --

1991 --
a solid ice pack
blocked the sea lanes
leading to northern Labrador.
And it brought the summer voyage
of Myron Arms and his companions
on his 50-foot sailing cutter
to an abrupt halt.

"That's not just ice out there,"

Myron lamented to a shipmate,
"it's a virtual barrier of ice,
covering up to 90 percent of the sea in places.
Ice so sharp
it could slice through our sailboat's fiberglass hull
like a knife through putty."

Since the pack did break up most years,

it seemed inexplicable
that it should be there now.
For Arms and his crew,
the ocean of ice brought frustration,
but for the people
living along more than 600 miles
of Labrador's eastern coast,
was a source of real hardship.

There are no roads in that part of the world;

everything comes in and out
by boat or small aircraft.
Emergency supplies
could be ferried in by commercial airlift,
but all the heavier items,
the normal requirements of daily life,
needed freight boats.
They wouldn't be coming that summer.

And for that matter,

the local fishing boats
wouldn't be heading out either.
The economy of the whole area
would take a deep plunge
as the ice made a shambles
of the mainstay fishing industry.

A whole summer season lost.

The worst year for ice in memory.

For Arms and his crew,

there was no choice but retreat.
After waiting nearly four weeks
for the ice to clear,
they were out of time.

But as they sailed homeward,

Arms found himself fixated
on the why behind the phenomenon
that had stymied them.

In the three years that followed,

Arms sought answers
from the best scientists
and climatologists around,
people who shared their time and knowledge
generously with Arms.

What he found, though, was that

no one knows for sure
what was going on that year,
or, in the longer view,
what for sure is happening with the ice
year after year.

Oh, there are plenty of theories,

and by the time Arms headed north again
in the same small boat three years later --
this time to find the passages open --
he had learned all of them.

In his book about that voyage,

Riddle of the Ice
(New York: Doubleday, 1998),
he not only recounts the journey,
but also explains each of the theories.

These include fascinating accounts

of the mechanics of ocean currents
and world weather systems,
and of the migration of pilot whales.

He introduces us to such notions as

the Great Conveyor Belt theory
of oceanic water flow
and the Halocine Catastrophe,
explains why the Atlantic
is saltier and warmer than the Pacific,
and, closest to his quest,
considers the latest scientific reasoning
on global warming.

But in the end,

he is no closer to a reliable answer
than when he first
bumped up against the ice pack
three years before.
"For every question answered by the experts,"
Arms writes,
"two more had risen to take its place.
For every conclusion
drawn in the scientific literature,
twice as many had been
qualified or contradicted or postponed,
pending further study."

Two things he did learn however.

First,

the answer,
if it is ever found,
will likely not be a simple one.

Second,

we can make a certain kind of peace
with complexity.

While we might crave simple answers,

we may be better to cherish
the "inherent messiness of nonlinearity,"
the complicated business
of living in a world
where a lot of the loose ends
continue to dangle.

Those two discoveries are useful

when thinking about
the Advent questions.
Why would God send a Savior into the world
without doing more to ensure
the immediate success of his mission?

What indeed, was his mission

and why does it have to be launched
all over again
with each wave of human beings?
Why would God intervene
in human affairs?
Why does God care?
What does Bethlehem mean anyway?

What does the coming of Christ --

like Myron Arms' wall of sea ice,
an "unsettling anomaly" --
tell us about God's plan of salvation?
Or is "plan of salvation"
too tidy an idea
for this untidy world?
How does the coming of Jesus
affect our behavior
and challenge us to change our ways?

In other words,

we stand with the psalmist
who pleads in our text:
"Make me to know your ways, O LORD;
teach me your paths.
Lead me in your truth, and teach me,
for you are the God of my salvation;
for you I wait all day long"
(vv. 4-5).

As we ponder, then,

the "Riddle of the Christ,"
our questions take us on a voyage
into the mind of God,
and give us a fresh look at
why a Savior suddenly and unexpectedly
appeared in Bethlehem of Judea.

A fresh look, yes,

but not pat answers.

We cannot understand Bethlehem,

if understanding it is even possible,
without remembering that
God is a God of paradox.

The Christmas story

is full of such anomalies.

It is to the shepherd caste,

marginalized and ignored,
often regarded as
men of violence, perjurers,
guys with chemical abuse problems,
guys with impulse control problems --
guys who can't get work anywhere else --
that the angelic choir appears
to announce the birth
of the Christ child.

When the shepherds find the Child,

he is where they might find
one of their flock:
in a place that was
unclean, unkempt and inelegant,
a smelly shelter for farm animals.

Neither the religious establishment

nor the political powers
were present
for the birth of the Messiah.
It wasn't that they'd refused to come;
they hadn't been invited.

When God could've intervened

in human history
by divine decree,
he chooses instead
to use the vehicle of human flesh.

Still, after years and years of Christmases,

we are no longer really surprised
by those paradoxes.
What continues to astound us instead,
and to soak up a lot of our daily energy,
is how our own lives can be
so complex and ragged around the edges.

And what can yet

astonish us even more
is that somehow,
though we can't really understand it,
that which began
with the birth in Bethlehem
can give us an anchor
for our lives,
a center that holds
when all around is as unstable
as last season's ice.

Arms made his second voyage

with a crew of four,
all young adults.
One of these,
identified only as "Blue,"
became argumentative and surly
every time Arms
as skipper
decided it was necessary
to run the sailing vessel's diesel engine.

Finally, Arms confronted the young crewman.

Blue, concerned for the environment,
found it especially irksome that
on a voyage to raise consciousness
about the buildup of greenhouse gasses,
Arms would run the engine at all.

Like any motor running on fossil fuel,

it contributed 22 pounds of carbon dioxide
to the atmosphere
for each gallon of fuel
it consumed.

Arms pointed out that

he actually agreed with Blue
in pure theory,
but he also lived with
the contradictions of modern existence.
He went on to say that
the choices humans face
regarding their impact on the environment
do not yield to simple
yes or no answers.

We live with the complexity.

And we do in areas

beyond the environment as well,
including
in the realm of the spirit.
In the face of the
magnificent contradictions of life,
we do well to embrace
the Christ of Bethlehem
and then to pray,
along with the psalmist,

"Make me to know your ways, O Lord;

teach me your paths.
Lead me in your truth, and teach me,
for you are the God of my salvation" (vv.4-5).

Expect help, courage,

hope, faith, forgiveness.
But don't expect any easy answers.